This is a post I wrote for my Animal Forteana blog, August 2014 -- reposting it here.
Giant Bug Zappers, Daisy the Goat, and Devil Dog Stew
Seriously. The mountain men monster hunters of Destination America's Mountain Monsters show built a giant 'bug zapper' trap to capture Mothman. Then they set up lit torches along a path -- all this in the woods -- to lure Mothman to the trap. A bit later, the torches were found re-lit, burning unattended. Why, Mothman must have done it! Because, the mountain monster hunters insisted, those torches were put out!
Three things disturb me about shows like this. One, the arrogance of the "investigators." Armed, tromping around in habitats, disturbing creatures just for the hell of it. They'd tell you, no doubt, that it's no mere joy ride, they are indeed chasing after mysterious -- and often dangerous -- creatures, which is very important business. The assumption however seems to be these mysterious creatures are inherently evil and deserve to be trapped, harassed, placed in captivity, and possibly killed.
|Ulisse Aldrovandi, Italian illustration.|
Two, in their lust for chasing down non-human beings, they are generally disrespectful of the environment. It's their personal monster playground. Hell, they almost set the place on fire in the Mothman episode. Building giant traps and luring would be monsters -- simply ridiculous. I assume they get permission from various authorities; Fish and Game, etc. before constructing their contraptions. (The website has a disclaimer about not attempting to build traps yourself, and getting permission from authorities.)
Exploiting animals for para-tainment; like Daisy, the poor goat used as bait. Now, Daisy, we were constantly assured, was not going to be harmed. But imagine Daisy's freaked out mind, and how can we be sure that something unpredictable could happen? Can these armed mountain monster hunters move fast enough to protect Daisy from a fast moving predator -- "monster" or not?
Destination America website, there is a recipe for 'Devil Dog Stew':
'Ever wonder what a Wampus Beast tastes like? How about the Ohio Grassman? All this
hunting for fearsome creatures on Mountain Monsters got us wondering...what would you
do with a trapped mountain monster? They might be kinda tasty, no?
We decided to find out and it turns out, mountain monsters make delectable meals.
Here is a recipe for one such creature.'
Of course I don't believe real devil dog meat -- or, hopefully, any kind of dog -- is the main
ingredient. The point here is the appeal to the gratuitous, the titillation factor.
program that relies on entertainment, and ignores facts and data. For example: Mothman
is not a giant moth with evil intent, akin to a malevolent version of Mothra, as the producers
and actors in Mountain Men would have us believe.
When it comes to the unexplained, including Mothman, producers have their own agendas.
They then set out to find willing participants who will partake in their made-up
Not to say that shows exploring UFOs, cryptids and other anomalous topics can't be, or
shouldn't be, entertaining. With all programming, not matter the topic, producers have their
agenda, and editing is brutal. But some do attempt to present a deeper look into whatever
phenomena is being explored. Shows like Mountain Monsters are gratuitous and are not
concerned at all with authentic cryptid research.